Digital Discourse Dangers: The Escalating Threats Following Libs of TikTok Tweets

Digital Discourse Dangers: The Escalating Threats Following Libs of TikTok Tweets

"Libs of TikTok Sparks Wave of Threats: A Disturbing Pattern Uncovered"

In Brookings, South Dakota, a university LGBTQ+ group grapples with hate mail, culminating in a terrifying bomb threat that unnerves students. Across the country, from San Lorenzo, California, to Philadelphia, Boston, and Washington, D.C., Pride events and medical facilities face a surge of threats and harassment. Then, in the summer and fall of 2023, public schools and libraries in California, Colorado, Oklahoma, and Wisconsin receive bomb threats, leading to evacuations and class cancellations. What ties these incidents together is their connection to the conservative social media channel Libs of TikTok.

Chaya Raichik, the far-right influencer behind Libs of TikTok, denies promoting violence and disavows any responsibility for the threats, citing the lack of arrests as evidence. However, an exclusive new research analysis by progressive group Media Matters for America, based on deleted tweets and extensive archives, reveals a disturbing and pervasive pattern. USA TODAY, collaborating with Media Matters, verifies over two dozen cases of bomb threats, death threats, and harassment linked to Libs of TikTok posts since February 2022.

While news reports have covered individual threats associated with Libs of TikTok, this comprehensive analysis exposes the extent of the issue, demonstrating a significant increase in threats against schools in the past two months. Media Matters utilized published news reports to identify over 30 potential threat incidents, and USA TODAY independently verified threats in more than two dozen cases. It is likely that the actual number of incidents is higher, as some threats may go unreported, and targets may hesitate to publicize their experiences due to fear of further harassment.

The unsettling revelation sheds light on the dark side of digital influence, raising concerns about the consequences of online platforms in amplifying threats and fostering a climate of intimidation. As authorities grapple with this evolving challenge, the impact of Libs of TikTok on real-world incidents underscores the urgent need for vigilance and accountability in the digital age.

"As Libs of TikTok Grows, So Does the Wake of Threats"

With a follower count surpassing 2.6 million on X (formerly Twitter), Libs of TikTok, curated by Chaya Raichik, has emerged as a digital powerhouse, but the expanding reach comes with a troubling consequence – a surge in threats. Threats that have prompted hospital evacuations, school and library lockdowns, and disruptions at various establishments, including bookstores, Pride parades, cafes, and even a dog rescue center, highlighting the tangible impact of online rhetoric.

The frequency and intensity of threats following Raichik's posts have raised concerns about the real-world implications of digital influence. Media Matters' LGBTQ+ program director, Ari Drennen, notes the challenge of insulating oneself from social media's ripple effects, especially in a country where individuals may take matters into their own hands.

Raichik, a former Brooklyn real estate agent, created the @LibsofTikTok Twitter handle in April 2021, intending to "raise awareness about the situation in America," specifically highlighting what she perceives as the sexualization of children in public schools. However, the account has evolved into a catalyst for right-wing outrage, particularly on LGBTQ+ issues. Elon Musk's amplification on X, along with support from conservative figures like Tucker Carlson and Joe Rogan, has propelled Libs of TikTok into a prominent position within the digital landscape.

Over 2½ years, the account has shared a consistent stream of videos, photos, and links, often featuring content from progressive leftists with derisive commentary from Raichik. While she doesn't create all the content she shares, Libs of TikTok's choice of targets can trigger a viral response, quickly spiraling out of control. The account's influence underscores the broader challenges of misinformation, online hate, and the potential for real-world consequences in the digital age.

"Libs of TikTok Sparks Real-World Consequences: A Digital Amplification of Threats"

Chaya Raichik's digital platform, Libs of TikTok, has become a formidable force in shaping online narratives, with each post instantly reaching a massive audience and sparking widespread dissemination. The magnitude of its reach, often reaching millions of views and tens of thousands of retweets and likes, underscores its potential to influence public opinion.

However, the darker side of this influence emerges in the wake of Raichik's posts, where threats and harassment often follow. Media reports and interviews have consistently pointed to a pattern – once Libs of TikTok directs attention towards a target, threats swiftly ensue. In the spring of 2022, Raichik turned her audience's focus towards doctors, hospitals, and medical facilities providing care to LGBTQ+ patients, particularly children.

On March 16, 2022, Libs of TikTok targeted Doernbecher Children’s Hospital in Oregon, leading to immediate harassment and threats against the hospital and its staff. The hospital released a statement revealing that the messages objected to gender-affirming healthcare and cited social media posts containing inaccurate or misleading information.

During the summer, Boston Children's Hospital became the next target. Raichik's tweets, including the sharing of a debunked video alleging the hospital's involvement in performing hysterectomies on children, triggered a surge of hostile internet activity, phone calls, and harassing emails. One threat on a far-right message board even mentioned executing doctors. The hospital's official Twitter feed acknowledged the campaign and the false video as the catalyst, leading to a federal investigation.

Subsequently, federal agents arrested 37-year-old Catherine Leavy, who pleaded guilty in September to making a false bomb threat against Boston Children's Hospital. The case serves as a stark example of the tangible consequences stemming from online misinformation and harassment, emphasizing the urgent need to address the intersection of digital influence and real-world threats.

"Healthcare Workers Bear the Brunt: Libs of TikTok's Relentless Harassment Campaign"

The relentless onslaught from Libs of TikTok continues, with healthcare workers becoming the latest targets of online abuse and threats. On September 18, 2022, the account directed its attention towards gender-affirming care at Akron Children’s Hospital in Ohio. The hospital was forced to take down a section of its website due to the intensity of the online abuse.

Shortly after, on September 21, the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia faced the brunt of Libs of TikTok's posts about the hospital's efforts to support parents of transgender children. The hospital responded by increasing security measures due to threats against staff. The scope of the harassment extends beyond large institutions, as individual doctors have also found themselves in the crosshairs.

In October, Dr. Katherine Gast, co-director of the University of Wisconsin-Madison’s UW Health gender services program, became a target after Raichik posted a video of her discussing gender-affirming operations. The subsequent harassment campaign, amplified by thousands of Twitter accounts, including that of Texas Senator Ted Cruz, left Dr. Gast facing doxxing, false claims about her practice, and harassing phone calls.

When confronted about the established pattern of harassment following her tweets, Raichik offers a simple explanation – she claims to be reposting content already shared publicly on social media. According to her, the goal of TikTok users is to gain views and become famous. However, Raichik's posts go beyond mere reposts, often featuring commentary that can fuel the vitriol directed at the subjects. A prime example in October involved a New York music teacher waving a Progress Pride flag, with Raichik's comment describing him as "an actual elementary school teacher in NY." The teacher, Eric Williamson, reported an immediate surge of hate mail after the post, expressing mortification at becoming a target of Libs of TikTok's campaign.

The disturbing trend underscores the real-world consequences of online harassment, particularly when wielded against individuals providing essential healthcare services. As the digital landscape continues to shape public discourse, the impact on the lives and well-being of those targeted demands a closer examination of the ethics and accountability surrounding digital platforms.

"Libs of TikTok: Unveiling the Tactics and Impact Behind the Controversial Account"

As Libs of TikTok's influence grows, so does the scrutiny of its tactics and the consequences of its posts. Chaya Raichik, the mind behind the account, often encourages her followers to contact the original poster directly, creating a dynamic that can escalate online conflicts. In one post last April, Raichik sarcastically urged followers not to let up on pressuring an Oregon school district supporting transgender students, acknowledging it as a call to action but framing it as a harmless mention on social media.

However, Libs of TikTok doesn't limit itself to posting solely public material. The account regularly features clandestine photos and videos, sometimes without the consent of the institutions involved. Additionally, some content is doctored or fake, a reality Raichik admitted in an interview with USA TODAY. An April 2022 incident, where she reposted debunked photos and claims about an elementary school teaching a supposed fetish for animal costumes, prompted her to be more cautious in vetting information.

In a curious move earlier this year, Raichik deleted all her prior tweets from 2022 and 2021, characterizing it as a "one-time editorial decision" without further explanation. Presently, she has labeled certain posts as "Scoops," suggesting original reporting not found elsewhere. Raichik claims to file public records requests to unveil new information, a departure from her initial approach of sharing content created by others.

Despite these shifts, Raichik's recent focus has been predominantly on public schools. Media Matters uncovered at least 12 instances in the past two years where Libs of TikTok posts about schools, districts, and teachers were followed by bomb threats – an alarming pattern that has intensified in the last two months. The account's evolving strategies and their real-world implications raise critical questions about the responsibility and accountability of online platforms in shaping public discourse.

"Bomb Threats Surge in Wake of Libs of TikTok Posts: Unraveling the Impact"

Since August 21, at least 25 bomb threats have targeted schools, libraries, administration buildings, and universities following posts from Libs of TikTok, as documented by Media Matters and verified by USA TODAY. The concerning trend exposes the real-world consequences of online content, with the most recent incident occurring after Libs of TikTok posted about a public library in Davis, California.

The library faced bomb threats and temporary closure after staff refused to allow a group to continue a public presentation that violated rules regarding transgender athletes. Despite the event occurring at a public library, the Davis Joint Unified School District received at least five bomb threats, leading to an FBI investigation.

Similar bomb threats have unfolded in recent weeks following Libs of TikTok tweets about schools across several states, including Oklahoma, Iowa, Massachusetts, Illinois, Wisconsin, Colorado, Washington, and Oregon. Despite the mounting evidence linking the threats to Raichik's posts, she remains unconvinced of any direct connection, suggesting that schools regularly receive bomb threats.

Raichik speculates that some threats may not be genuine, questioning the selectivity of which threats make the news. However, victims and experts argue that the consistent pattern following Libs of TikTok posts goes beyond coincidental timing. The surge in bomb threats underscores the urgent need to address the intersection of online content, digital influence, and real-world consequences, raising critical questions about the responsibility and accountability of social media platforms.

"Libs of TikTok Sparks Real-World Chaos: A Disturbing Pattern Emerges"

The ripple effects of Libs of TikTok's online content are turning into a disturbing pattern of real-world consequences, with bomb threats and evacuations following closely on the heels of the account's posts. In Arapahoe County, Colorado, the Cherry Creek School District faced a bomb threat in September after being targeted in a Libs of TikTok post claiming the district housed "pornographic" books in elementary school libraries. The post led to a barrage of harassing communications, including phone calls, emails, and social media posts, prompting an evacuation of multiple buildings.

Cherry Creek's superintendent, Chris Smith, directly linked the bomb threat to the online bullying and homophobic views expressed about LGBTQ+ books, emphasizing that the attacks were driven by hate and had no place in the schools. School safety consultant Ken Trump expressed skepticism about the string of threats following Libs of TikTok posts, stating that such a series of coincidences would be highly unlikely.

The impact of Libs of TikTok extends beyond schools. South Dakota State University's Gender and Sexualities Alliance became the target of a bomb threat after the account reposted a video of a drag queen, misrepresenting it as a "family-friendly" event hosted by the Alliance. The subsequent bomb threat prompted Alliance president Alyssa Gonzales to come out to her family, revealing the personal toll of the online chaos sparked by Libs of TikTok.

As the line between online content and real-world consequences blurs, questions surrounding the responsibility of social media platforms and the potential for harm resulting from online influence demand urgent consideration.

"Defiance in the Face of Hate: Activists and Performers Rise Above Online Threats"

The impact of online threats and harassment, triggered by posts from Libs of TikTok, has resonated beyond the virtual realm, reaching the lives of activists and performers across the country. Alyssa Gonzales, president of the South Dakota State University Gender and Sexualities Alliance, found herself coming out to her family after the Alliance became the target of a bomb threat following a misrepresented video reposted by Libs of TikTok. Despite the adversity, Gonzales and her colleagues have chosen defiance, reading out some of the absurd messages in ridiculous voices at their meetings as a means of reclaiming their narrative.

Similarly, Panda Dulce, a drag queen from the San Francisco Bay Area, faced disruption during a library event targeted by a Libs of TikTok tweet. The event was subsequently disrupted by members of the Proud Boys, who hurled homophobic slurs and threats at Dulce. Despite the challenges, Dulce refuses to let hate dictate her actions, continuing to lead Story Hours and emphasizing that extremists' attempts to grab attention will not deter her.

These stories underscore the resilience of activists and performers in the face of adversity, with the unwavering commitment to their causes prevailing over online hate and real-world threats. While the incidents have exposed the dark side of online influence, they have also become catalysts for individuals to proudly assert their identities and push back against intolerance.

In conclusion, the stories of Alyssa Gonzales and Panda Dulce exemplify the resilience and determination of activists and performers in the face of online threats and real-world harassment spurred by platforms like Libs of TikTok. Despite the challenges, these individuals have chosen defiance, using humor and unwavering commitment to their causes as a powerful response to hate. The incidents underscore the complex interplay between online influence and its tangible consequences, prompting discussions about the responsibility of social media platforms and the need for strategies to address the escalating impact of virtual harassment on real lives. As these individuals continue to rise above adversity, their stories serve as a testament to the strength of the human spirit and the capacity to turn moments of darkness into opportunities for empowerment and change.

News

Money, Tech